ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Throat culture is the golden standard for diagnosis of group A streptococcal (GAS) pharyngitis. However, because it is a time-consuming procedure, antibiotics are often empirically administrated. Rapid antigen tests (RATs) can detect bacterial infections within 15 minutes, thus helping to reduce unnecessary administration of antibiotics. METHODS: In total, 108 patients, between 3 and 17 yr of age, who visited our hospital from August 2011 to July 2012, were tested for suspected acute pharyngitis with two RATs––SD Bioline Strep A (SD, Korea) and BinaxNOW Strep A (Binax, Inc., USA)––as well as throat culture. We compared the sensitivity, specificity, and consistency of the two RATs and assessed the clinical manifestations of GAS pharyngitis. RESULTS: Of the 108 patients, 15 were confirmed to have GAS pharyngitis by throat culture. The SD test showed a sensitivity of 93.3% and a specificity of 97.8%; the positive and negative predictive values were 87.5% and 98.9%, respectively. The Binax test showed a sensitivity of 86.7% and a specificity of 100%; the positive and negative predictive values were 100% and 97.9%, respectively. The Kappa values for conformity degree were high, 0.887 and 0.918 in the SD and the Binax tests, respectively (P=0.00). Clinical manifestation assessment of GAS pharyngitis indicated that scarlatiniform rash and strawberry tongue were significantly associated signs (P<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: GAS pharyngitis diagnosis based on clinical manifestations alone has practical limitations. The two RATs are useful as substitutes for throat culture and their frequent use in clinical settings is advisable.
Subject(s)
Animals , Humans , Rats , Anti-Bacterial Agents , Bacterial Infections , Diagnosis , Exanthema , Fragaria , Pharyngitis , Pharynx , Sensitivity and Specificity , Streptococcus pyogenes , TongueABSTRACT
OBJETIVO: Avaliar o impacto da realização rotineira da prova rápida para pesquisa de estreptococo do grupo A no diagnóstico e tratamento da faringotonsilite aguda em crianças. MÉTODOS: Estudo prospectivo e observacional que contou com a utilização de protocolo de pesquisa estabelecido na Unidade de Emergência do Hospital Universitário da Universidade de São Paulo para o atendimento de crianças e adolescentes com faringotonsilite aguda. RESULTADOS: Com base na avaliação clínica, dos 650 pacientes estudados, antimicrobianos seriam prescritos para 389 indivíduos (59,8%) e, com o uso da pesquisa de estreptococo do grupo A, foram prescritos em 286 pacientes (44,0%). Das 261 crianças que não receberiam antibiótico pelo quadro clínico, 111 (42,5%) tiveram pesquisa de estreptococo do grupo A positiva. O diagnóstico baseado no quadro clínico apresentou sensibilidade de 61,1%, especificidade de 47,7%, valor preditivo positivo de 44,9% e valor preditivo negativo de 57,5%. CONCLUSÕES: O diagnóstico clínico da faringotonsilite estreptocócica mostrou baixa sensibilidade e especificidade. O uso rotineiro da prova rápida para pesquisa de estreptococo permitiu a redução do uso de antibióticos e a identificação de um grupo de risco para as complicações da infecção estreptocócica, pois 42,5% dos pacientes com prova rápida positiva não receberiam antibióticos, se levado em consideração apenas o diagnóstico clínico.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the impact of the routine use of rapid antigen detection test in the diagnosis and treatment of acute pharyngotonsillitis in children. METHODS: This is a prospective and observational study, with a protocol compliance design established at the Emergency Unit of the University Hospital of Universidade de São Paulo for the care of children and adolescents diagnosed with acute pharyngitis. RESULTS: 650 children and adolescents were enrolled. Based on clinical findings, antibiotics would be prescribed for 389 patients (59.8%); using the rapid antigen detection test, they were prescribed for 286 patients (44.0%). Among the 261 children who would not have received antibiotics based on the clinical evaluation, 111 (42.5%) had positive rapid antigen detection test. The diagnosis based only on clinical evaluation showed 61.1% sensitivity, 47.7% specificity, 44.9% positive predictive value, and 57.5% negative predictive value. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngotonsillitis had low sensitivity and specificity. The routine use of rapid antigen detection test led to the reduction of antibiotic use and the identification of a risk group for complications of streptococcal infection, since 42.5% positive rapid antigen detection test patients would not have received antibiotics based only on clinical diagnosis.
OBJETIVO: Evaluar el impacto de la realización de rutina de la prueba rápida para investigación de estreptococos del grupo A en el diagnóstico y tratamiento de la faringotonsilitis aguda en niños. MÉTODOS: Estudio prospectivo y observacional que contó con el uso de protocolo de investigación establecido en la Unidad de Emergencia del Hospital Universitario de la USP para la atención a niños y adolescentes con faringotonsilitis aguda. RESULTADOS: Con base en la evaluación crítica, de los 650 pacientes estudiados, antimicrobianos serían prescritos a 389 individuos (59,8%) y, con el uso de la investigación de estreptococos del grupo A se los prescribieron a 286 pacientes (44,0%). De los 261 niños que no recibirían antibióticos por el cuadro clínico, 111 (42,5%) tuvieron investigación de estreptococos del grupo A positiva. El diagnóstico basado en el cuadro clínico presentó sensibilidad del 61,1%, especificidad del 47,7%, valor predictivo positivo del 44,9% y valor predictivo negativo del 57,5%, CONCLUSIONES: En este estudio, el diagnóstico clínico de la faringotonsilitis estreptocócica mostró baja sensibilidad y especificidad. El uso de rutina de la prueba rápida para investigación de estreptococos permitió la reducción del uso de antibióticos y la identificación de un grupo de riesgo para las complicaciones de la infección estreptocócica, pues el 42,5% de los pacientes con prueba rápida positiva no recibirían antibióticos si se llevara en consideración solamente el diagnóstico clínico.
Subject(s)
Adolescent , Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Male , Anti-Bacterial Agents/therapeutic use , Antigens, Bacterial/analysis , Pharyngitis/diagnosis , Pharyngitis/drug therapy , Streptococcal Infections/diagnosis , Streptococcal Infections/therapy , Streptococcus pyogenes/immunology , Tonsillitis/diagnosis , Tonsillitis/drug therapy , Acute Disease , Emergency Service, Hospital , Pharyngitis/complications , Prospective Studies , Respiratory Tract Infections , Time Factors , Tonsillitis/complicationsABSTRACT
1266 school children aged 6-15 years at 10 schools in Hanoi were enrolled into an investigation on Streptococci group A infection. At the pharynx a prevalence of 15.3% was shown. Predominant titre of antibody against streptolysine O was from 25 to 100 Todd units and only 9% had got the titre over 240 units. Alpha hemolytic Streptococcus viridans could be wrongly identified with beta hemolytic one leading to an error to 60% in bacitracine tests. Pseudo-positive identification may happened in ASLO test if the sample of serum had been infected